Springe direkt zu Inhalt

DHC Lecture mit Eberhard Kienle (CNRS | Institut français du Proche-Orient)

From Contestation to Dislocation? The State of the Middle Eastern State

After initial enthusiasm, the ‘Arab Spring’ has increasingly come to be seen as a harbinger of turmoil, chaos and disorder. Today, a growing chorus of otherwise divergent voices bemoans the departure of the former autocrats and the demise of the anciens régimes. Once again, forty years of tyranny seem to be preferable to a night without government, if necessary at the price of foreign intervention.
Taking issue with such nostalgic views of the past and short term policy prescriptions, the paper briefly recalled that violent domestic conflict in a number of Arab countries was ultimately prompted by decades of authoritarianism, not by the protests that began in 2010 and 2011.

In a nutshell, the paper argued that similarities and differences at the levels of popular contestation, regime responses, and ensuing political dynamics reflect the historical trajectories of the states concerned, in particular aspects of state formation. For instance, more consolidated and therefore ‘stronger’ states underwent various forms of (regime) transformations while less consolidated and ‘weaker’ ones disintegrated and even collapsed. In all cases, though, contestation and its consequences reflect the growing incapacity of (authoritarian) political regimes to adapt to changes in the international economy that over the past decades reconfigured interests and thus eroded the domestic coalitions from which they drew support.

In Kooperation mit: